Guarding Stars

Released: 2026
Director: Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum
Writers: Erin Cardillo, Richard Keith, and Gina Matthews
Stars: Leighton Meester, Jared Padalecki, and Andy MacDowell as “Momma Connie”
Where to Watch: Netflix
Holiday score: 6
They do some Christmasy things, but the music is pretty good and raises the score.
Romance score: 7
Good characters, good story, good ending.
Comedy score: 6
Some great one-liners.
The Review
Today I am reviewing the movie Guarding Stars. It stars Leighton Meester as the tough, no-nonsense bodyguard Hannah and Jared Padalecki as the handsome actor Jack. To answer your first question, yes, this movie does follow the classic bodyguard romance movie story line, just like the 1992 movie, The Bodyguard, with Whitney Houston and Kevin Costner. Oh, you were thinking of a different bodyguard movie? OK, you must be thinking of the 2018 TV show, Bodyguard, with Richard Madden and Sophie Rundle? No, not that one? OK, then it must be the 2017 movie, The Hitman’s Bodyguard, with Ryan Reynolds and Samuel L. Jackson. What’s that? The Hitman’s Bodyguard isn’t a romance movie? Then why did I fall in love with Samuel L. Jackson?
Anyway, it’s nice to see a movie flip the script. You’ve got the handsome movie star man being protected by the tough, autistic woman bodyguard. Sorry, what’s that? That’s not what you expected? I didn’t expect it either, a woman bodyguard is a nice change and she's a badass. Oh, you meant the autistic part? You don’t think she’s autistic? The trailer doesn’t mention that? Well, the best movies don’t tell you things, they show you things and this movie absolutely shows us that Hannah is absolutely autistic. She is totally on the spectrum. She for sure has a touch of the ‘tism. Still don’t believe me? Well I’ll prove it to you in my review.
So, Jack, the big movie star, is getting ready to film the third installment in his massive movie franchise “The Pallbearer” (oh, I didn’t make that up, that’s really in the movie), but he wants to visit his ailing mother in the hospital before he flies off to Dubai. The problem? Jack has tons of fans and at least one dangerous stalker. So, Jack highers a company to ensure his safety during his visit.
Enter Hannah, the tough as nails, but obviously a woman, bodyguard. I really don’t why Hollywood thinks they can put a movie star in frumpy clothes and no make up and we will believe they are unattractive. Did we think Rachel Leigh Cook wasn’t pretty in She’s All That? Nope. Did we think Sandra Bullock wasn’t beautiful in Miss Congeniality? No way. Did we think Anne Hathaway wasn’t attractive in The Princess Diaries or The Devil Wears Prada or Les Mis? Nu-uh. What’s that? Anne Hathaway doesn’t get a glow up in Les Mis? Um ok, maybe, or maybe I’m just a fan of short hair.
But, I get it. This movie wants to show that Hannah is tough and the only way is to make her look tough is to make her look plain because beautiful women can’t be strong. Yeah, right. Tell that to my wife...actually don't tell her. I've been pretending her arm punches don't hurt for years. I'd like her to keep believing I am tough. The movie wants to make Hannah look tough, but they also wants to do a Miss Congeniality style glow-up on Hannah and boy do they make a meal of it. Hannah goes from frumpy FBI agent to dollar store country bar Barbie. I wouldn't call it a glow-up as much as a bedazzle-up.
I think they also want to show that Hannah is focused and driven. So focused that she only cares about her job. She doesn’t care about makeup or clothes or anything but protecting people. You may say Hannah is just a driven person, but I say that she has intense special interests. Do you know who else has intense special interests? Autistic people…and people who play pickleball.
So Hannah and her team take Jack to his mom’s hospital and of course his family mistakes Hannah for his new girlfriend and of course Hannah goes along with it. What’s the harm, it’s just a couple of hours, right? RIGHT? Bwahahaha, nope. During the visit, Jack commits to spending Christmas with his mom because it might be her last. Oh don’t get mad, its true and that’s why Jack really wanted to go home. Hannah isn’t happy about the extra time spent in Montana, but she agrees as long as Jack strictly follows her very specific rules. Hmmm, Hannah is very strict about rules and routine. You might say she was just trying to protect Jack, but I’d say she likes rigid routine and has an aversion to change. Do you know who else loves routine? Autistic people...and factory workers.
So we have a big city girl who spends Christmas with a (formerly) small-town man on his family’s ranch. It's a holi-rom-com shocker, I know. Will Hannah and her team be able to protect Jack from his very dangerous stalker? Perhaps, but if he died, the sequel could be a revenge movie. A holi-rom-com version of John Wick…with autism. I’m so totally in. Will Jack see through Hannah’s tough exterior to the beautiful, autistic woman hiding beneath the surface? Possibly, but what is she hiding under? She has no make up and very simple clothing, that’s not a costume, for most people that’s a Saturday afternoon. Will Hannah be able to get through Christmas with Jack’s family and all the noise and hugging and eye contact? Maybe, and you should definitely watch Guarding Stars to find out and here’s why.
First off, I like the roll reversal in this movie. Having the woman be the bodyguard for the man is different than every other bodyguard movie. Can you imagine Whitney Houston being the bodyguard for Kevin Costner? Her voice was so strong, she wouldn’t need a gun. Now, I was worried it would be a bit cheezy, and it kind of was, but it definitely of worked.
Second, I love a good enemies to lovers story. Jack is a movie star who does what he wants without regard for planning or safety. Hannah just wants to follow her strict plan to keep Jack safe. Hannah is brave, but often underestimated. Jack is also brave, but often overestimated. Hannah is a strong woman who is haunted by the death of people she loves. Jack is a strong man who is also haunted by the death of people he loves. Jack is a handsome man who could use someone to love and take care of him. Hanna is a beautiful woman who could also use someone to love and take care of her. Hmmm, maybe they aren’t so different after all. What’s that? Do I think Jack has autism too? No, don’t be silly. No, you’re being silly.
Third, I really liked the supporting characters. Hannah’s team was a group of tough security professionals, but they throw out funny one liners, usually based on something serious Hannah said. Hanna is a pretty serious goose. Hmmm, you may say Hannah is just serious, but I say that Hannah appears serious because she has a tough time communication and reading social cues. You know who else has a tough time with communication and reading social cues? Autistic people…and IT people.
Jack’s niece and nephew are super sweet and they really take to Hannah. Jacks nephew even tries to teach Hannah how to hug because she just isn’t a hugger. Hmmm, you may say it’s perfectly normal to avoid contact with strangers, but who doesn’t love a good hug from a sweet kid? Autistic people, that’s who. Well, and hypochondriacs.
Fourth, this movie was kind of exciting with more than a couple of twists and turns. Have you ever watched a holi-rom-com and knew everything that would happen? Of course you have. The real question is, have you ever watched a holi-rom-com where you didn’t know everything that would happen? Well, there were times in this movie when I was full on surprised. It was wonderful and a little exciting. I would almost call this movie a holi-rom-com-action movie. What’s that? Like John Wick? No, not like John Wick. More like a less exciting Princess Bride.
So you see, Hannah was definitely autistic…or maybe an IT support person or a pickleball player or a factory worker or a hypochondriac. Wow, that convers a lot of people. Sounds like we all may have a touch of the 'tism. Isn't it wonderful?
Conclusion
If want a holi-rom-com with no action, no fun, and no autistic people...you should probably look somewhere else.
If want a holi-rom-com with a little action, a good amount of comedy, and a lot of heart…you should watch Guarding Stars.





Comments