The 12 Dates of Christmas

Released: 2026
Director: David Lipper
Writers: Seth Howard, David Lipper
Stars: Lucy Hale, Ian Harding
Where to Watch: Disney+
Holiday score: 2
For some people, the theme of family challenges over the holidays is as important as gingerbread and tinsel so I’ll accept it. That said, it is only dealt with a few times and the majority of this movie is about bad dates.
Romance score: 1
More time is spent on how not to do romance than how to do romance. While that could be entertaining, it ends up not romantic. Like, not at all.
Comedy score: 1
The premise sets the stage for a very entertaining movie…and then fails completely.
The Review
Today I’m reviewing the new movie The 12 Dates of Christmas. Let me start my review with a story. When I was just 12-years-old, all I wanted for Christmas was a Sega Master System. On Christmas morning, I ran downstairs to see if Santa had visisted our house. I found my stocking full of goodies and a present under the tree with my name on it. It was the perfect shape and size for the Sega I truly wanted. Score, Santa had delivered again! I could barely wait my turn to open the gift. After patiently waiting for my family to open their gifts, it was finally my turn. I tore off the wrapping paper, ripped open the box to find…a Coleco Handheld Quarterback game. You know the game with a two inch screen with flashing lights that could barely be considered a video game? I was crushed. It was the second-worst holiday ever, right after the year the Easter Bunny gave us carob bunnies instead of chocolate bunnies.
What does this have to do with my review of The 12 Dates of Christmas? Well, one day I was checking out the various streaming services, looking for new holi-rom-coms and I came across The 12 Dates of Christmas. I was immediately intrigued because it checked so many boxes for me. Its a new movie, released just this year. Nice! It was on Disney+, a very reputable streaming service. Sweet! And it has recognizable actors like Lucy Hale who you might know from Pretty Little Liars or The Hating Game and Ian Harding who you might know from Pretty Little Liars or The Hater. Hmmmm, Pretty Little Liars, The Hating Game, and The Hater. Their resumes sound remarkably similar. That was a red flag I should have noticed.
I was so excited to watch this movie that I wrapped up the review I was working on and started watching The 12 Dates of Christmas immediately and it was…awful. Absolutely, completely, and totally awful. Now, some movies are so bad they are awesome. Think old kung fu movies or The Room. Not this movie. This movie falls into another category of awful, movies that are so bad they actually leave a scar on your soul. Movies like Joe Dirt and Grown Ups 2. You are left with one question for the writer, director, and actors, “Who hurt you?” That said, I love reviewing awful movies so let’s do this!
The 12 Dates of Christmas stars Lucy Hale as Christina. Christina is a furniture restorer who lives in a small town and just can’t find the right man. OK, most movies asks the audience to suspend their disbelief for something. For super hero movies we are asked to believe that super heroes exist. I used to believe that super heroes exist, but every time I try to fly, I end up braking a limb. For any western movie, we are asked to believe that the 1800s didn’t smell like a wet skunk stuck in an old boot. The people from that time look so dirty, you can practically see the scent coming off them. For the last Indiana Jones movie, we are asked to believe that an old man can jump off anything taller than a step-stool and not break both their legs.
In The 12 Dates of Christmas, we are asked to believe that Christina would have any sort of trouble finding a man or a woman or any person. Is she attractive? Yup. Is she successful? Uh-huh. Is she a sociopathic maniac that lures men into her basement so she can force them to act in her improvisational production of Really Little Men? No, but I’d watch that. Look, it's easier for me to believe that there is a man who gets so angry that he turns into a big, green rage monster than it is for me to believe that Christina has any trouble finding a man.
Christina’s mother also can’t believe that she can’t find a man and she is pissed about it. So pissed that at Christmas dinner, Christina's mom sets an empty space for Christina’s non-existent boyfriend like she was celebrating Passover. The problem is, Christina’s family isn’t Jewish and Christina doesn’t give a flying fudge that she is single. That said, Christina does care that her mom is major jerk, I mean who wouldn’t. My mom was a perfect mother who loved me enough to give me a Handheld Quarterback for Christmas and a carob bunny for Easter. To avoid future bullying, Christina commits to her mom that there will never be an empty seat at their table again. Unless they convert to Judaism and it’s Passover, which isn’t at Christmas, I know.
Eight months pass very quickly and Christina hasn’t gone on a single date. I guess she just doesn’t care about finding a man because she totally could, if she really wanted to. When it hits September 1, Christina’s best friend reminds Christina of her commitment to her mom and offers to help her find a man. Christina resists, but she remembers what her mom did last Christmas and she worries she might go a step further this Christmas. Maybe set her up with one of her first cousin? Ewe! So, Christina agrees to let her best friend match her up on twelve dates before Christmas in the hopes one of those dates will produce a suitable match.
Enter Peter, played by Ian Harding. No, Peter is not one of the twelve dates. Peter has just moved back to town and he hires Bridget to remodel the house he bought. Bridget and Christina are frenemies, but Bridget often buys stuff from Christina’s store, so she puts up with her. When Christina meets Peter, she fall for him immediatly. So what's the problem? Well Bridget is an actual sociopath and she talks to Christina like she and Peter are together so Christina believes it and leaves Peter alone.
Will Christina keep her commitment to go on twelve dates before Christmas? After date number one, she might change her mind. It is an epic fail that would put anyone off of dating forever. Will one of those twelve suitors be the Prince Charming she is not really looking for? Totally, because Christina’s friend knows how to suss-out men on a dating app, right? RIGHT? Will Christina figure out that Peter is not actually dating Bridget and he is free to date whomever he pleases? No, she won’t and it doesn't matter because there is no way in hell you should care because this movie is a Handheld Quarterback when you really want a Sega Master System.
This movie is a beautiful idea executed in the worst possible way. The twelve dates of Christmas, great idea. Have Christina go on some absolutely terrible dates. Perfectly fertile ground for humour and hijinx, but all that grows in this garden is dandelions and beets. The movie produces plenty of characters that could be funny, but they just aren’t and I can’t put my finger on why. Is it the acting? Maybe. Is it the writing? Possibly. Does it matter? No. No it does not. It’s not funny and its a crying shame.
I also take issue with the amount of time Christina and Peter share the screen together. This is the second movie I have reviewed this year where the main characters spend very little time together. Not surprisingly, both movies stink. I know some marriages thrive on separation. Think of your parents who slept in separate beds? Oh, your parents didn’t sleep in separate beds? That’s because it’s dumb and a recipe for disaster!
Falling in love is about getting to know someone. It’s about learning their cute little quirks like she snorts when she laughs. He sings in the car. She loves cats more than humans. He likes to kill people in video games. You know, the wonderful things that make us fall in love with someone. If you don’t spend time with someone, how will you ever fall in love with they way she pretends to crush people’s heads with her fingers?
I’ll could spend all day complaining about this movie, but I’ll end with one last thing. The musical score. The musical score for this movie is so cheap and so bad that I imagine this was the conversation in the producer room.
Producer 1: “We spent all the money for this movie on ‘big stars’, we need to save some money on the music.”
Producer 2: “OK, this is going on Netflix so we’ll keep the music quality at ‘steaming movie’ level.”
Producer 1: “We need it cheaper.”
Producer 2: “OK, we can do a ‘Hallmark movie’ level.”
Producer 1: “Still too much.”
Producer 2: “‘Evangelical church band’ level?”
Producer 1: “Cheaper.”
<Producer 2 is starting to sweat>
Producer 2: “OK, ‘teenager who releases their own music on YouTube’ level?”
<Producer 1 Shakes head>
<Producer 2 is getting visually upset.>
Producer 2: “‘80s home movie’ level.”
<Producer 1 keeps eyes on Producer 2 without blinking, waiting for Producer 2 to respond.>
Producer 2: “‘Temu AI music created by a beaver’ level?”
Producer 1: “Perfect.”
It’s hard for me to un-recommend any movie more than this one. It's so bad that it isn't good-bad, it’s just bad, bad, bad.
Conclusion
If want a holi-rom-com that helps you find humour from someone’s bad dating life...you should probably look somewhere else.
If want a holi-rom-com with known actors, a quality premise, and absolutely nothing good to show for it...then you should watch The 12 Dates of Christmas.





Comments